Ask A Question About Islam And Muslims

17 Questions

"Esoteric teachings" is somewhat broad and could include many things. 

Taking an overall view, there is no formal or jurisprudential requirement within Islam that esoteric learning be conducted through a teacher. (Some specific groups, like some Sufi groups, may have their own view, but I am speaking from an overall perspective.)

That said, it is generally easier to learn any subject through a teacher, and there is a virtue to the tradition of person to person transmission of religious sciences, including esoteric sciences. Virtually every religion and group worldwide passes on these things on a person to person basis, rather than in a depersonalized manner. There may be other advantages to having a teacher as well, just as, in mundane life, there are other advantages to having a teacher (for instance, in mundane life, the teacher may help with networking or write letters of recommendation). 

When dealing with esoteric or spiritual matters, it is also helpful to have someone who can offer oversight or guidance because, due to the nature of the subject, some people might fall into psychological or other problems, such as delusions, and so it is helpful to have someone offer a reality check. 

However, sometimes one doesn't find a compatible teacher. When discussing esoteric or spiritual matters, given the nature of the subject and the close relationship that occurs, there is also the challenge that it is difficult to determine the reliability of teachers and sometimes there is some fraud or abuse. Teachers are also not infallible and may go towards an unhealthy direction over time.

So, basically, it is good to try to learn what you are seeking from a teacher. However, if you can't find a suitable one, you can pursue these things on your own.

When people seek greater learning or insight of a spiritual or esoteric nature, there is also a certain spiritual machinery that operates in our world that also might facilitate certain types of learning. For instance, at the least, one might attain some blessings or guidance from the Prophet (S) or awliya (A). However, again, it is good to be careful about falling into delusions. (For instance, someone who is imagining they are having daily conversations with Imam Mahdi, is probably imagining that they are having daily conversations with Imam Mahdi, or conversing with something other than Imam Mahdi.)

Regarding types of esoteric learning historically associated with Islam, and, in particular, the Imams of the Shi'a, one could look at the writings of M. A. Amir-Moezzi. The Encylopaedia Iranica has a few entries on this as well, if you search it. 

I am sure there will be some other insights from contributors here on this, but I thought I'd add a few thoughts.

May Allah bless and assist you in your quest! 

Bismillah

Thank you for your question. Annihilating in God's Essence is impossible to conceive of as the human, who is essentially a limited being would have to become unlimited. This is a contradiction as something cannot be limited and unlimited at the same time. Rather, what is meant by the term annihilation is the annihilation of the ego such that all that a person witnesses within their being are the signs of God. Those signs, which manifest divine perfections, seem unlimited to us as their limitations are beyond our perception. At this stage, a person only sees God through the mirror of their soul. This view is compatible with Shii scriptural sources such as this part of the munajat of Shaban:

"My Lord, (please) grant me absolute devotion to You and illuminate the vision of our hearts by the light of their gaze looking towards You. Until the vision of our hearts pierces the curtains of light to reach the core of supremacy and that our souls become suspended by the majesty of Your Holiness."

May you always be successful

Bismillah

Thank you for your question. The very meaning of unveiling (kashf) is to life the veil of hidden meanings and realities and thereby comprehend them. Unveiling is the primary epistemological tool in irfan.

May you always be successful 

There are many paths to spirituality and 'irfan; the one you are faced with is not the only one. It might work out for you, or it might not. If it doesn't, inshallah you will find a different path that is more suitable for you.

It is not possible to say from your question whether this specific 'irfani path, or 'irfan in general, will lead you to hell or not. Many things can lead people to hell. It often depends on what we do with them. Only Allah knows the end of all things, although it is sometimes obvious when someone is going down a slippery slope and a wrong path.

The only thing that is for sure is that when a person is certain they are guaranteed paradise, that person is in danger of hell.

Although I am sure you have done so already, I would recommend sincerely praying for guidance. If you are an Ithna Ashari Shi'i, or even if not, you could also write an ariza to Imam al-Zaman (A) asking for guidance specifically on how this path would affect your afterlife. You could also consult istikhara for guidance. 

This is of course in addition to keeping your two eyes open. (Or, in this case, three or four eyes, if one counts the inner and the outer eyes.)

Wishing you the best!