['Aalim Network QR] Justice of God

["Mustafa F"]

Salaam Alaykum

Please review the links provided below.  Please feel free to refer any
additional or specific questions to the 'Aalim Network

wa salaam,

Mustafa F
Acting Moderator, 'Aalim Network
_____________________________________________________________________

QUESTION:

Asalaam Alaykum

Recently I was having a discussion with a Sunni brother about the Shia 
belief of 'Adl which is according the Shaykh Kashif ul-Ghita that "God 
the Almighty is not unjust to anybody, nor does He commit any action 
which could be considered bad by man's primordial sense."

Does this mean that Allah (SWT) is compelled to do justice which is in 
accordance with man's primordial sense?  Or does Allah (SWT) do justice 
as He pleases, even if it may be different from man's definition of 
justice?  

The Sunni brother told me that they don't believe in that 
definition of 'Adl and since 'Adl is an essential belief for a Muslim, 
does this make them kafir?  

----

ANSWER:

[Moderator's Note:  Both articles were obtained from www.al-islam.org]

 <<Al-Adl.html>> 

 <<divine justice.html>> 

Attachment Converted: "c:\program files\eudora\attach\Al-Adl1.htm"

Attachment Converted: "c:\program files\eudora\attach\divine justice1.htm"