1. Ask A Question About Islam And Muslims
  2. Ask A Question About Islam And Muslims

Ask A Question About Islam And Muslims

69 Questions

Why can't we follow multiple Marjas when we find that more than one is knowledgeable, and we believe that each gives Fatwas after extensive research on Quran and Hadith, with some being more knowledgeable in certain matters and others in other matters?
Sayyed Mohammad Al-Musawi

Proper Taqleed is following and implementing the verdict of the most knowledgeable Mujtahid. It is not a pick and choose or taking what you like. The verdicts of the most knowledgeable (Al-A'lam) among all the Mujtahids must be followed. If you have real evidence the Marje' A is more knowledgeable in any field of Fiqh than other Mujtahids, then you can follow him in that field only. Having such evidence is not easy at all and it needs witnesses from the high category of Ulama (Ahlul Khibrah).

Wassalam.
Which Marjas permit a mature (Rashida) girl to marry without permission from her guardians?
Zaid Alsalami

Bismihi ta'ala

In general our esteemed Maraji' permit a female who meets the shar'i requirement of being a balighah rashidah, to marry without a need of a guardian's consent, as long as the condition of her being so is correctly defined and understood. 

It is not just a matter of maturity, but that she has absolute independence in her affairs, not just financial, but social as well. And that she is completely consciously aware of what is good and what is bad for her, and is competent in her decision making. 

And Allah knows best
I understand that it will be obligatory to attend Friday prayers if it is led by the infallible Imam (as) or his specific representative. Would a Marja' be considered as such a representative?
Sayyed Mohammad Al-Musawi

Real Marja' of Taqleed who has all the conditions mentioned by the Imam (AS) is a representative of the Imam (AS).

Wassalam.
I am new to Shia Islam, and I am unsure how to select the Marja of Taqlid to follow, particularly considering I reside in California, USA. Could you provide guidance on this matter?
Zaid Alsalami

Bismihi ta'ala

1. I would recommend you learn as much as you can about Islamic jurisprudence, and the method of selecting a Marja' Taqleed. This lesson will in shaa Allah help you: 

2. Once you have developed a good understanding of selecting a Marja' taqleed, you will know that it is important to follow the "most learnt", and most commonly followed. 

3. Should you have any further questions, speak to your local qualified scholar.

With prayers for your success