Ask A Question About Islam And Muslims

6 Questions

In Nahj al-Balaghah, it is related that Imam 'Ali said, "A woman's jealousy is disbelief, and a man's jealousy is faith."

This is generally explained by saying that a woman should not be jealous of her husband for lawfully taking another woman (such as a co-wife), because it is allowed. However, a man's jealousy over his woman will impel him to protect her from other men.

(Sadly, many customs and traditions worldwide regarding women boil down to protecting women from overeager men!)

Either this attribution to Imam Ali is accurate; or, possibly, there is a cultural element to this attribution to Imam 'Ali since many cultures have this sense of machismo.

Al-Kafi also contains a hadith which says that a woman's ghirah stems from love (al-Kāfī, vol. 5, p. 506, no. 6). That is, because she loves her husband, she wants him for herself.

Some narrations discuss ghirah relating to Allah; for instance, because of his ghirah, Allah hates the forbidden things. This is somewhat similar to the idea of sexual morality (just as the womenfolk are described as the haram and off limits to other men, the sins are described as haraam and off limits to people) but is also broader. It seems to be the Islamic way that the Old Testament idea of a "jealous God" is revised. 

Yusuf's brothers were envious of him when he was a young boy before his message, because Yuqub's favoting him over them. Obviously, Yakub as a prophet had valid reasons to favor Yusuf and was never emotional.

Wassalam.

No. Your question seems to reflect very limited side of Paradise and ignore very important facts about Paradise. Paradise does not have materialistic desires only, but more importantly has spiritual happiness and Ridgwan Minallah Akbar ( Pleasure from Allah which is Greater). Paradise is the place of the Prophets and Infallible Imams and people of Pardise enjoy the neighborhood of the Prophets 

and the Infallible Imams and have the pleasure of seeing them.

I advise you to read more about Paradise and don't restrict it to what lay people say.

Wassalam.

I was hoping that one of sisters will answer this question but as did not see any reply I am answering briefly:

Jealousy of the wife over her husband can be against the rule of Allah Who allowed the man under certain conditions to have another wife. Jealousy against a rule from Allah is direct or indirect objection on Allah's rule, that is why it is bad.
Jealousy of man over his wife is against any relation between his wife and any other man, which is always a sinful act because she is a married woman and never allowed any act or word which can initiate a relation with another man. Husband's jealousy over his wife (without false allegations) is good to protect her and the whole family from a sinful act. You can then compare between a jealousy going against Allah;s rule and a Jealousy to protect the wife and the family from a sinful act.

'Wassalam.